Controversy Erupts Between the Town of Warwick and A Popular Farm

A growing controversy in Orange County has put one popular Warwick farm in the middle of a heated debate between supporters and the town where it operates.

Over the last few days, there have been numerous claims circulating on social media that the Town of Warwick is trying to shut down the Blue Arrow Farm located at 86 Glenwood Rd, in Pine Island, NY. A petition has been circulating, supporters have been speaking out, and emotions are clearly running high.

But Town officials say that narrative isn’t exactly accurate.

Dispute Over Blue Arrow Farm in Warwick, NY

In a public statement, Warwick Town Supervisor Jesse Dwyer pushed back on the idea that the Town is targeting the farm, making it clear they actually support operations like Blue Arrow.

“Operations like Blue Arrow Farm contribute to Warwick’s character and economy,” Dwyer said, pointing to the growing role agritourism plays in the region. And that’s an important piece of this: farms like Blue Arrow aren’t just businesses anymore. They’ve become destinations. Places people go to gather, unwind, and support local.

What’s The Problem?

According to the Town, the issue isn’t the farm itself. It’s how some of the events are being run.

Officials say the property sits in a primarily residential and agricultural zone, and some activities go beyond what’s currently approved.

The farm’s popular Wednesday night car shows are a major sticking point. While they’ve become a draw, the site is only approved for smaller gatherings. The Town claims those events often bring in 300 to 600 people, along with far more vehicles than permitted.

Officials also say there have been more than 130 police-related incidents tied to the property since 2019. In 2024, the Town issued a formal site plan violation outlining multiple issues, and said the owner was allowed to work toward compliance, but said that didn’t happen.

What Supporters Are Saying

At the same time, there’s a very vocal group of supporters who see Blue Arrow Farm as much more than just a venue.

A petition now circulating on Facebook describes the farm as a “valued animal sanctuary” that provides care and rehabilitation for rescued animals. Supporters say the weekly car shows and live music events aren’t just entertainment, they’re a critical source of funding that helps keep those operations going.

SEE ALSO: Big Changes Planned at Walmart Stores in New York

They also argue that the events provide a safe, family-friendly space, support local businesses, and create a sense of community that’s hard to find elsewhere.

What Happens Next?

Dwyer says this situation ultimately comes down to enforcement, not elimination. “This is about ensuring that all activities are conducted safely, responsibly, and in compliance with local laws,” he explained.

And that’s where things get complicated.

Across the Hudson Valley, more farms are leaning into events and entertainment to stay afloat. At the same time, towns are being forced to balance that growth with zoning laws, safety concerns, and quality of life for nearby residents.

For now, Warwick officials say they're still open to working with Blue Arrow Farm to find a path forward, one that allows the farm to continue operating, while also bringing everything into compliance.