A Fishkill Pizza Shop Just Got A Big “One Bite” Score From Dave Portnoy

Barstool's One Bite Pizza Tour in The Hudson Valley

By now you've probably heard that Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports was driving through the Hudson Valley on his way to New York City from Saratoga Springs.

The Barstool Founder was seen around Dutchess County on Saturday September 26th, 2026. From what we saw at the time he made a stop at 2 local pizzerias, likely for his One Bite pizza reviews.

Portnoy goes around the country trying different, small local, pizza shops and gives them a 1-10 rating after taking One Bite (more like 4-6 bites, but you get the picture).

We saw pictures of Portnoy at Hudson & Packard and Pipinelli's, both in Poughkeepsie and a the brand new pizza spot in Fishkill called Mommò Pizza Napoletana.

Barstool and Portnoy released the Pipinelli's and Hudson & Packard One Bite reviews, and they both received great scores.

Pipinelli's: 7.7
Hudson & Packard: "Monstrous" 7.9

Now, it's Mommò's turn.

The One Bite Review: Mommò Pizza Napoletana in Fishkill, NY

Mommò Pizza is one of the newer pizzerias here in the Hudson Valley.

They used to be a food truck, but then opened their store front on Robinson Street in Fishkill back at the beginning of August 2026.

Portnoy said that while they were driving through Fishkill and remembered that Mommò had been suggested before on the One Bite app, however he wasn't interested because the food truck at the time was just serving Neapolitan Pizza. Which is not his style.

But when Mommò opened their store front, they started serving New York style slices and that got Dave's attention.

As he starts the review Portnoy states that the pizza look "really, really good" shouting out all the fresh flavors from local farms in Fishkill.

Then he dives right in. Any guesses as to what he gives Mommò Pizza Napoletana? Watch below:

I don't know if you heard that, but Mommò received an 8.2! That's an incredible score!

Mommò might be the new kids on the block in Fishkill, but we have a feeling this One Bite review is going to bring them a ton of new business.

Controversy with Mommò Pizza Napoletana One Bite Review?

It seemed like there could have been a possible mix up with Portnoy's order at Mommò.

Dave famous doesn't like Neapolitan  pizza, like a margherita pizza, and always orders a plain pie. However, there was some conversation that Dave got a margherita pizza by mistake.

El Presidente argued that the pizza he ate was "as cheese pizza as it gets." Will the Barstool and One Bite fan base let this possible infraction slide? We hope so.

Sounds like Portnoy liked it either way!