Is There A Secret Menu at The Crumbl in Poughkeepsie, New York?

First Hudson Valley Crumbl Location Opens in Dutchess County

The Hudson Valley was buzzing when pink pastel signs started popping up on Route 9 in Poughkeepsie in May of 2025.

What did the signs say that had everyone so excited? "Coming Soon!" with a delicious looking cookie and in small letters at the bottom... Crumbl.

Locals have been begging for a location in the Hudson Valley. The 2 closest Crumbl locations were in Danbury, CT and in the Lower Hudson Valley in Yorktown Heights.

By June, Crumbl Poughkeepsie was ready for their grand opening just in time for the kids to get out of school and celebrate with their pick from the ever changing menu at Crumbl.

Speaking of their menu, Crumbl is baking up something mysterious.

Does Crumbl Poughkeepsie Have a Secret Menu?

For those not familiar with how Crumbl works, each week there is a menu of six varieties of flavors.

Currently, the week of September 7th through the 13th consist of the following flavors:

Milk Chocolate Chip
Cookies & Cream Cake ft. Oreo
Confetti Milkshake Cookie
Brownie Batter Cookie
Pumpkin Cake Cookie
Salted Carmel Cheesecake Cookie

There's usually a mix of classic cookies like Chocolate Chip and seasonal favorites like the Pumpkin Cake Cookie.

During the recent menu drop, Crumbl also announced the addition of a new menu item.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Crumbl (@crumbl)

The Crumbl Secret Menu item is available at all Crumbl locations, however the flavor of the secret menu item is different at each Crumbl location.

How To Find Your Local Crumbl Secret Menu Flavor

Crumbl fans who want to be surprised by the Secret Menu flavor can head out to their local shop and ask for the Secret Menu flavor.

Those who want to know what they're expecting can open the Crumbl app and click on "Flavors." Follow the Secret Menu button to the map and locate the store in your town.

For instance, here's what the Poughkeepsie Secret Menu looks like for the week of September 7th through the 14th:

Keep an eye out for Crumbl Secret Menu updates all year round!